An Argumentative Indian

An Argumentative Indian | Book Review

An Argumentative Indian is a highly dense and researched book. There are atleast 3 or more references on almost every page. And each of them seems to be reliable. There could have been no better effort to understand the origin of India and more importantly the 'Idea Of India' in such short length.

The whole book is about contradiction. India is land of contradiction. So many people, so many beliefs, huge conflict! Many of us have very distorted version of what India is, what it stands for, based on their born prejudices, which is quite hard to get rid of. And this book becomes so important considering the current extreme situation of the country.

Sen writes about two extreme conditions, people, beliefs, opinions and states to make sense of the whole situation. Many of times the one side have clear superiority to other but sometimes things are not exactly as they look. For example consider the comparison between the Gandhi's India and that of Tagore's. These two great men respected each others and their beliefs. But there were obvious reasons about there thinking differently when it came to Indian Identity. And both of them had reasonably sound grounds to hold to beliefs and ideals they had.

There many more contradictions, let it be left vs right, Indian tradition vs the western influences, india vs china and so on. Well the book might seem biased to some. It might be or it might not. Sen do have his own beliefs, and they are quite liberal, tolerant and harmless. So someone like me who would has neutral mindset, incline more towards his beliefs. Because the opposite of these beliefs seems non sensical.

Its not a perfect book, it will cause many Argumentative Indians to Argue. But as long as the argument is constructive, reasonable and induce fair solutions, then the book serves it purpose.

Comments

Maqbool | Movie Review

Maqbool - 2003 Directed by : Vishal Bhardwaj Maqbool is a clever character study of a man's gradual descent from loyalty to betrayal; from respect to rage; from reason to madness; from life to eventual and tragic death. Vishal Bhardwaj's Maqbool is powerful adaptation of Shakespeare's tragedy, Macbeth, which deals with themes of loyalty, betrayal, love, guilt and death. Set in underworld of Mumbai, Maqbool is realistic portrait of world of gangsters' and their psyche. It is oftentimes dark, serious, repressed and at unexpected times wickedly funny. Jahagir Khan aka Abba ji(Pankaj Kapoor with his Brando-esque mannerisms), is an aging don of Mumbai, who runs the crime world, with the help of his loyal lieutenant, Maqbool(Irrfan Khan) and Kaka, his loyal(underrated Piyush Mishra). Purohit and Pundit, are two utterly corrupt cops who help them fight their rivals(played charmingly by Naseeruddin Shah and Om Puri respectively). They are film's charm and wit. ...

Has Babasaheb Ambedkar's Vision Come True?

Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, fondly known as Babasaheb, remains an iconic figure in Indian history, celebrated for his relentless fight against social injustices and his pivotal role in framing the Indian Constitution. Soon India will mark the completion of 75th years of our constitution. It becomes imperative therefore, to scrutinize whether the dreams harmonised by Babasaheb have indeed been materialised or not. The present landscape of the country sees a resurgence of the ideas of Ambedkar for multiple reasons. And his ideas do supply a solid framework - still, for many of the contemporary issues, which even now seem insurmountable. Central to his philosophical vision for the country was the establishment of a society grounded in equality and justice. His work "Annihilation of Caste" remains a seminal treatise on the subject, where he critiques the rigid and dehumanizing caste hierarchies. For him, the exploitation of Dalits was the major problem that sprouted from this rigid caste ...

untitled

Lying as he is - Oblivious, on a dusty road of Fractured Earth, I see in him a look that is Not human. For he seems worried not About things he had not done Or regrets about his youth. Nor there is a choice, a hesitation, Etched into every fabric of his being. Amidst this burden of thoughts, These echoes of guilt and memories Like restless, unkind ghosts Haunts the corridors of my mind, There blooms an innocence, Like the fleeting grace of God, Unaware of his Purity. He being only a pup, afterall. Looking at him, it seems Universe revealed its secrets To me. But the world weeps Alone, still. ---------- SECOND VERSION Lying as he is - Oblivious, on a dusty road of Fractured Earth, I see in him a look that is Not human. For he seems worried not About things he had not done Or regrets about his Youth. Nor there is a choice, a hesitation, Etched int...

SUVISO

Search This Blog