An Argumentative Indian

An Argumentative Indian | Book Review

An Argumentative Indian is a highly dense and researched book. There are atleast 3 or more references on almost every page. And each of them seems to be reliable. There could have been no better effort to understand the origin of India and more importantly the 'Idea Of India' in such short length.

The whole book is about contradiction. India is land of contradiction. So many people, so many beliefs, huge conflict! Many of us have very distorted version of what India is, what it stands for, based on their born prejudices, which is quite hard to get rid of. And this book becomes so important considering the current extreme situation of the country.

Sen writes about two extreme conditions, people, beliefs, opinions and states to make sense of the whole situation. Many of times the one side have clear superiority to other but sometimes things are not exactly as they look. For example consider the comparison between the Gandhi's India and that of Tagore's. These two great men respected each others and their beliefs. But there were obvious reasons about there thinking differently when it came to Indian Identity. And both of them had reasonably sound grounds to hold to beliefs and ideals they had.

There many more contradictions, let it be left vs right, Indian tradition vs the western influences, india vs china and so on. Well the book might seem biased to some. It might be or it might not. Sen do have his own beliefs, and they are quite liberal, tolerant and harmless. So someone like me who would has neutral mindset, incline more towards his beliefs. Because the opposite of these beliefs seems non sensical.

Its not a perfect book, it will cause many Argumentative Indians to Argue. But as long as the argument is constructive, reasonable and induce fair solutions, then the book serves it purpose.

Comments

The White Tiger | Movie Review

The White Tiger - 2021 Directed By : Ramin Bahrani The White Tiger have many kind of problems, but they are not very stark. They are not significant, but still quite obstruct this film to be a lot better than what it is. This is awkward, lukewarm and confusing film throughout, but enjoying nonetheless. As an adaptation of Arvind Adiga's Booker Prize winning book, this film is somewhat accurate and faithful to its source material. The book was also quite lukewarm and confusing. And if I am allowed to be little more critical, it was gimmicky. And the film somewhat makes that gimmick much more obvious and visible here. There are instances where you have to join the universal opinion and question your own judgment because of it. When you read a book or watch a film, people are so crazed about that piece of work, but you don't see the greatness of the work which the people around you are referring to. And more often than not, you question your own judgement in that case ...

Locke | Movie Review

Locke - 2013 Directed By : Steven Knight I like to think that Locke is perhaps about stoicism. Its a lesson about stoicism. Perhaps about how to handle situations which are out of control. And in the end stoicism prevails. Perhaps its not hardcore or perfect form of stoicism which is described in the books. Ivan Locke has his faults. He shouldn't have been in that position in the first place. It isn't his dead father's fault that he has impregnated a women who is not his wife. Or he should have been more sensitive to the woman who carries his child. He is sensible man though, his soul is being tortured, his mind is not at rest and his whole world is falling apart in front of him. Yet he bears it all. He is determined to his thing, right thing. And probably thats the basic idea of stoicism, isn't it? Sometimes it is confusing to define stoicism. It has its shades, its variants. Ivan Locke has his variants. He has a deep urge to save the ruins of his already d...

#Day 66, An Old Man And His Precious Tapri Filled With Classic Books

As I was crossing a street in some part of Jalgaon, I came across a little book shop. It was a like a typical Indian tapri. To be clear it indeed was a tapri . The old man, the owner of that shop, evidently had to sustain by selling cigarettes, paanmasalas , gutkas and similar stuff. Presumably he couldn't sustain himself by selling only the books. And the books too, which no one reads anymore. I stopped to have a look. English Classics interested me more than anything else. Sadly they were the most torn out pieces amongst the whole) entire bunch. My eyes smiled after detecting George Eliot, Henry James, Thackeray and alike. What suprised me the most however was the fact that how passionate the old man was while showing and talking about his books. Particularly when I said he had very good bunch of classic books. He grew more and more passionate as I was looking for everything in his little tapri . And he knew each and every book and could discern what each particular book ...

SUVISO

Search This Blog