Skip to main content

Mank | Movie Review

Mank - 2020 
Directed by : David Fincher 

It is not clear that how much of all this is closer to actual reality. And thats the biggest problem with this film. Everything else is as meticulous as any other Fincher movie. One cant help but question about what this film wants to say regarding the event that happened many many decades ago, and whether is it really an accurate depiction of what have had actually happened at the time. The answer for it is not clear nor easy to find. 


For those of you don't know Mank is story about Herman Mankiewicz aka Mank(Gary Oldman) who wrote the screenplay for supposedly greatest film ever made, Citizen Kane. And it is a film about, the relationship of Orsen Welles(Tom Burke) with Mank and his own contribution towards the screenplay. And the main center point of the story being, how much is written by each of them. And this film takes an Anti-Welles approach and practically gives all the credit of the screenplay to Mank. Fincher portrays Welles as an evil genius who wants to steal or even buy the script of Kane and make it his own. 

It is the certainty of the film about the actual events happened is bugging me more than anything. No one can be sure about what have had actually happened between them, except Welles and Mank themselves! It is safe to say that Fincher is fictionalising many things. Particularly the last arguing scene between both of them where Welles literally offers Mank 10,000 dollars to make him let go of the script and abandon the credit for it; how someone goes on to guess what happened between them two. Also the connection between Upton Sinclair and Mank claimed to have been completely fictional. Also the visit of Marion Davies(Amanda Seyfried) with Mank after the script written, is supposedly not a true fact. And there are moments of invented fiction here and there to make look Mank more the person which Fincher thinks him to be rather than what he really might be. 

Surely the makers of the film might have their reasons to believe what they do. But we are free to interpret. Except what is the center point of the film, the story and accurate account, Mank gets everything right. The score, the acting, the cinematography, the accuracy in showing the bygone period, the editing, directing and every other technical aspect hits bull's eye, as Fincher every time does. 

Gone Girl was the last film David Fincher directed before Mank, a totally different movie. Mank might be very personal to Fincher, its screenplay was written by his father, late Howard Fincher, it was his passion project he wanted to make for a long time and finally made it. I am personally confused with Fincher's biographical films, Mank and before that The Social Network. The Social Network was also pretty debatable for presenting the facts which might or might not be true. But regarding Mank, for Fincher fans, myself included, Mank is not the movie we wanted or expected. 

Rating: ★★★
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The White Tiger | Movie Review

The White Tiger - 2021 Directed By : Ramin Bahrani The White Tiger have many kind of problems, but they are not very stark. They are not significant, but still quite obstruct this film to be a lot better than what it is. This is awkward, lukewarm and confusing film throughout, but enjoying nonetheless. As an adaptation of Arvind Adiga's Booker Prize winning book, this film is somewhat accurate and faithful to its source material. The book was also quite lukewarm and confusing. And if I am allowed to be little more critical, it was gimmicky. And the film somewhat makes that gimmick much more obvious and visible here. There are instances where you have to join the universal opinion and question your own judgment because of it. When you read a book or watch a film, people are so crazed about that piece of work, but you don't see the greatness of the work which the people around you are referring to. And more often than not, you question your own judgement in that case ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Pyaasa | Movie Review

Pyaasa - 1957 Directed By : Guru Dutt One of the true pleasures of watching Pyaasa is Guru Dutt's face and his genuine expressions. It doesn't seem like he is playing a character; he is playing himself. Such is the power of those expressions. The genuineness of eyes, the horror in the same eyes when he is exposed to the dirty existence of social hypocrisies and selfishness. Or genuine delight over simplest of things. Or the childlike wonder about the world around him. Everything about that face felt so real and human.  Here is an actor who knows art of acting. While others are waving their hands obsessively, exaggerating expressions, speaking dramatically and mechanically, leaving no traces of subtlety; Dutt is subtle, hardly exaggerating or waving his hands or making faces. He is still. His every word leaves an impact, whether he is angry, sad, disappointed, horrified or happy. Every emotion is portrayed to its utmost perfection. Here is someone who is magical, mys...
Post a Comment
Read more

Locke | Movie Review

Locke - 2013 Directed By : Steven Knight I like to think that Locke is perhaps about stoicism. Its a lesson about stoicism. Perhaps about how to handle situations which are out of control. And in the end stoicism prevails. Perhaps its not hardcore or perfect form of stoicism which is described in the books. Ivan Locke has his faults. He shouldn't have been in that position in the first place. It isn't his dead father's fault that he has impregnated a women who is not his wife. Or he should have been more sensitive to the woman who carries his child. He is sensible man though, his soul is being tortured, his mind is not at rest and his whole world is falling apart in front of him. Yet he bears it all. He is determined to his thing, right thing. And probably thats the basic idea of stoicism, isn't it? Sometimes it is confusing to define stoicism. It has its shades, its variants. Ivan Locke has his variants. He has a deep urge to save the ruins of his already d...
Post a Comment
Read more